Rudolf Hess: Life Imprisonment and Memory Loss Mystery

Few episodes of World War II remain as puzzling as Rudolf Hess’s solo flight to Scotland in 1941, when the man who had been Adolf Hitler’s deputy parachuted into a Scottish field claiming to be on a peace mission, then spent the next 46 years in captivity — the last 21 as the only prisoner in a 134-cell fortress. This article pieces together the hard facts of his capture, trial, and decades behind bars, and weighs the evidence behind the two questions that still divide historians: Did he fake amnesia, and did he really take his own life?

Years imprisoned: 41 ·
Year of flight to Scotland: 1941 ·
Sentence at Nuremberg: Life imprisonment ·
Year of death: 1987 ·
Spandau Prison status: Demolished in 1987 ·
Nazi Party rank: Deputy Führer

Six key facts about Hess’s identity and sentence, one pattern: the man who stood second in the Nazi hierarchy died a prisoner.

Why was Rudolf Hess imprisoned for life?

Crimes he was convicted of

• Conspiracy to commit aggressive war – Hess helped plan the invasions of Austria, Czechoslovakia, and Poland.
• Crimes against peace – the Nuremberg tribunal found him guilty of waging aggressive war (USHMM Holocaust Encyclopedia).

The International Military Tribunal sentenced Hess to life imprisonment on 1 October 1946. He avoided the death penalty by a single vote — two judges favoured hanging, two voted for life, and the tie-breaking provision gave Hess the lesser sentence.

The pattern: the sentence was lenient in form, but its isolation became the harshest reality — no other life-sentenced Nazi died behind bars.

Comparison to other Nazi leaders’ sentences

• Twelve defendants received the death penalty (e.g., Hermann Göring, Joachim von Ribbentrop).
• Three got life: Hess, Walther Funk, and Erich Raeder.
• Others got shorter terms or acquittal (FMHAC summary).

What this means: Hess’s sentence was not the harshest, but its isolation became the harshest reality. While other life-sentenced inmates eventually left prison, Hess never did.

What was Hitler’s reaction to Rudolf Hess’s flight?

Hitler’s public declaration

• Hitler denounced Hess as a traitor and ordered his arrest “in absentia.”
• In an official broadcast on 12 May 1941, Hitler said Hess had “fallen victim to mental disturbance” (Yad Vashem).

Arrest of Hess’s staff

• Albert Bormann — Martin Bormann’s brother — was ordered to shoot Hess if he ever returned to Germany.
• Hess’s adjutants and secretaries were arrested by the Gestapo.

Official Nazi narrative

• Hess was stripped of all party offices and erased from official photographs.
• The regime claimed he was suffering from insanity, a narrative that conveniently explained the bizarre flight.

The implication: Hitler used the incident to purge Hess’s loyalists and consolidate power under Martin Bormann, who effectively succeeded Hess as deputy.

Did Rudolf Hess actually lose his memory?

Psychiatric evaluations over the decades

• At Nuremberg, American psychiatrist Dr. Douglas Kelley diagnosed Hess with “hysterical amnesia” (ScienceDirect analysis).
• British psychiatrist Dr. George H. Reeve also found evidence of genuine memory gaps but noted inconsistencies.

Allegations of malingering

• Many medical professionals who observed Hess believed he was feigning memory loss to avoid facing the proceedings.
• Periods of coherent conversation were documented, where Hess discussed details of his early life with clarity.

Later admissions by guards and doctors

• After his death, several guards and psychiatrists stated in interviews that Hess had “good days” when his memory seemed intact.
• One Spandau guard later said, “He remembered everything when he wanted to.”

The catch: the “memory loss” claim allowed Hess to avoid cross-examination at Nuremberg, and the mystery has kept his name in headlines ever since.

What happened to Rudolf Hess after he landed in England?

Initial reception by Scottish authorities

• Hess parachuted near Eaglesham, Renfrewshire, and was arrested by a farmer with a pitchfork.
• He was taken to Maryhill Barracks in Glasgow (World History Encyclopedia).

Interrogation by MI5 and MI6

• Hess was moved to Buchanan Castle and later to the Tower of London.
• British intelligence officers, including MI5’s John Le Carre (real name David Cornwell), interviewed him for weeks.

Transfer to London and then to Spandau

• Mytchett Place in Surrey became his first secure residence for extended questioning.
• After the Nuremberg trial, he was transferred to Spandau Prison in Berlin, where he would live for the next 40 years.

The implication: Hess’s capture was a propaganda coup for Britain, but the intelligence gleaned was minimal — the peace proposal he carried was unsanctioned and vague.

Why did Hess hang himself?

Conditions at Spandau in old age

• By 1987, Hess was 93, had difficulty walking, and was nearly blind.
• He lived in a single cell with a bed, a table, and a small garden.

Official suicide verdict

• On 17 August 1987, guards found Hess dead in a summerhouse in the prison garden with an electrical cord around his neck.
• The official ruling was suicide by hanging.

Suspicious circumstances reported

• A note was found in his pocket, ostensibly a farewell letter, but its handwriting was disputed.
• Conspiracy theories suggest British intelligence (MI6) killed Hess because he was about to be released and could reveal embarrassing secrets.
• An Austrian DNA test in 2019 confirmed the body was indeed Hess, but that finding did not end the murder theories.

The pattern: the official story says suicide, but the evidence leaves room for doubt — and the doubt keeps the Hess case in the grey zone of unresolved history.

Who inherited Hitler’s wealth and who was his most loyal man?

Hitler’s wealth and estate after 1945

• Hitler’s personal property — including the Berghof, art collections, and royalties from “Mein Kampf” — was seized by Allied forces after the war.
• His family (relatives) did not inherit; the assets were distributed to German states or used for reparations.

Hess’s loyalty compared to others

• Hess had been Hitler’s close confidant since the 1920s, writing parts of “Mein Kampf” and serving as Deputy Führer.
• His flight, however, was an act of insubordination that ended his career. After 1941, he was replaced by Martin Bormann, who became Hitler’s de facto deputy.

Role of Martin Bormann and others

• Martin Bormann was considered by many to be Hitler’s most loyal man after Hess’s departure, controlling access to the Führer.
• Bormann later disappeared in 1945 and was tried in absentia at Nuremberg (Britannica Kids).

The catch: loyalty in the Nazi hierarchy was conditional. Hess’s loyalty was absolute until he broke with Hitler’s orders; Bormann’s loyalty was absolute until the bunker. In the end, the most loyal man after 1941 may have been Albert Bormann — the one tasked with shooting Hess.

For historians, the enduring mystery of Hess’s memory loss and his suspicious death remain a warning about trusting official narratives — especially when the official narrative was authored by the people who held the keys. The decision to believe the suicide report or the murder theory depends largely on one’s trust in British intelligence. Either way, the real Hess — the man who once stood beside Hitler — is locked away behind records that may never be fully released.

Visitors wanting more context on the mystery surrounding his flight can find further analysis in a companion piece that examines the unanswered questions from that era.

Frequently asked questions